Reader's Digest: Jill Hennessy

Free Spirit
By Diane Sewell

Jill Hennessy, star of the hit series Crossing Jordan, lusts for life

On a damp, grey morning in Soho, in New York City, Jill Hennessy arrives for our sit-down interview at a small hotel precisely at 11 o’clock, looking gorgeous and relaxed in jeans and a leather jacket. Within five minutes it feels like I’ve been reacguainted with a high-school chum. Such is the disarming personality of the 36-year-old who loves to cook and ride motorcycles and has been dubbed one of Hollywood’s hottest female actors.

Hennessy was born in Edmonton in 1969 – three minutes after her identical twin sister, Jacqueline. After their parents split up, the girls, 13, and their younger brother remained with their father.

After finishing high school, Hennessy left the family home in Kitchener for Toronto in search of an acting career. There she hooked up with an improv-comedy troupe and studied with the famed Second City, earning food money by playing guitar on downtown streets. After appearing in 1988 with her sister (now a Toronto writer-editor) in the film Dead Ringers, starring Jeremy Irons, she got a role in the stage production of The Buddy Holly Story and landed in New York. That’s where her career really took off. She got her big break in 1993 when she signed a three-year contract with the Emmy-award-winning TV series Law and Order, to play assistant district attorney Claire Kincaid, a role that endeared her to viewers all over the world.

These heady days, Hennessy is the star of NBC’s Crossing Jordan, now in its fifth season. Her portrayal of Dr. Jordan Cavanaugh, an edgy and outspoken Boston medical examiner, won her a nomination for the People’s Choice Award in the show’s first season. In 2000, Hennessy married actor-businessman Paolo Mastropietro; the couple, along with their two-year-old son, Marco, divide their time between Los Angeles and New York.

RD: You’ve stayed out of the tabloids and people say you’re very down-to-earth. How have you managed not to get swept up in fame?

Hennessy: It’s funny; I really don’t comprehend the whole fame aspect. I work on a TV show, and I focus on learning my lines and doing a good job. I don’t have a sense that it’s being transmitted to millions of people. I only see it when somebody stops me on the street, and to be honest, most of the time that’s nice – especially when I’m in Canada, walking around Toronto or Montreal or Waterloo, where my father lives.

RD: How has becoming a mother changed your life?

Hennessy: I don’t sweat the small stuff as much. And before I had Marco, I’d always felt this need to keep moving, a sense that I was not in the right place. I don’t have that feeling anymore.

RD: What was it like growing up as a teenager without a maternal figure?

Hennessy: It forces one to be so self-reliant, especially as a girl. Young women have so much pressure; they have to appear a certain way; behave a certain way. Not having my mother there forced me to figure out how to deal with situations – How should I dress? Should I wear makeup? Should I not?

RD: Your career took off with Law and Order. When your three-year contract expired, why did you leave such a high-profile role?

Hennessy: For the very reason that it was high profile. I was becoming a typecast; I was trying to audition for the movies, and what was frightening was to find out that a lot of casting directors didn’t want to see me because they thought I was a buttoned-up attorney type. I loved the show, but I wanted to play other characters.

RD: What role has been the most challenging so far?

Hennessy: Jacqueline Kennedy, whom I played in a miniseries. I knew that in playing somebody so recognizable I’d practically be begging for scrutiny. Also, one of my worst fears is to offend people, to dishonour someone as respectable as Jackie. But because I was so afraid, I wanted to tackle this.

Jackie had a particular way of speaking, a not-quite-British accent, so I got a dialect coach, and every day I’d listen to tapes of Jackie to get into her cadence. Afterwards, a few people stopped me, and one person said, “My good friend was Jackie’s chauffeur and says you’re the only person to get her joyful qualities, her voice.” That’s what resonated with me, hearing from people who knew her that I got a general sense of her.

RD: In an industry that worships youth, what’s your philosophy on aging?

Hennessy: I don’t believe in fighting it. And it would be terrifying to believe 36 is over the hill! Some of the hottest women I know are in their 50s. What really ages you is to feel inactive or unneeded, and I felt that way sometimes in my 20s. So age is more a state of mind.

RD: You have been described as the “thinking man’s hottie.” Do you think being sexy, intelligent and down-to-earth are contradictory qualities?

Hennessy: Oh, no. I can only think of what I find attractive. I love to see someone who’s comfortable with themselves and goes the extra mile to make other’s feel comfortable. When I worked with Richard Gere on Autumn in New York, he’d come to work so relaxed and go out of his way to say hello to everybody. If he discerned that somebody was feeling upset, he’d ask them what was going on, try to help them. It was classy. I find that very sexy.

RD: Your identical twin sister is a freelance editor and writer in Toronto. Do people ever stop Jacqueline in the street because they think she’s you?

Hennessy: All the time, but she’s very gracious about it. I apologize to her, but she says, “No, no – I’ve met the nicest people.” People tell her, “You really inspired my daughter to go to college.” She’ll say, “Actually that’s my sister, but it’s really good to meet you.”

RD: You once told an interviewer you liked a man who embraces life and wants to be on a long journey with no particular plan or destination in mind. Is that an approach to life that still appeals to you?

Hennessy: I love somebody who’s open to options. It can be good to have a plan, but I’m a big believer in seizing the opportunities life throws in front of you. My husband, Paolo, is passionate about life, has a lot of courage and loves to seize the moment. I find that very attractive.

RD: Being a Canadian among Americans, how do you react if anyone speaks out against our refusal to join the war in Iraq?

Hennessy: That’s never come up; I hear nothing but praise for Canadians. At least where I live in California and in New York, the admiration and respect people have for Canadians is astounding. They perceive us as incredibly open, level-headed, down-to-earth. They feel we don’t react impulsively to situations.

RD: Lots of actors use their public profiles to influence politics. Have you ever been tempted?

Hennessy: I’m an actor and I go to work and recite somebody else’s dialogue. If I were to go out and express my political beliefs, I would have to take a few years off and study what I wanted to talk about. I’m not an expert; I try to watch a broad range of media to get different points of view. There are always three sides to every story: your version, my version and the truth. Unfortunately, I see some people speaking who seem to have heard only one point of view and that’s dangerous.

RD: Do you miss Canada?

Hennessy: I miss it so much it makes me cry sometimes when I think of it. I love the United States, and I’m very grateful for what this country has given me. But now that I’ve got some credibility behind me, I’d like to someday go back and produce films in Canada. Also I would love to record a duet album with my sister; she’s a brilliant singer. We’d do a bunch of Canadian covers – Blue Rodeo, Gordon Lightfoot, Sarah McLachlan.

RD: Do you still play guitar?

Hennessy: I play for my son. And when I was pregnant, we recorded a soundtrack for Crossing Jordan. It was a dream come true. I started playing when I was in Toronto; I’d play on Queen Street West for food money and that was one of the best jobs I ever had. I’d play, then go to the store and buy some yogourt or a can of soup.

RD: So you went from leaving home at 17 to busk in Toronto to being a happily married mom and an actor with your own TV series. Do you think that’s fate or self-determination?

Hennessy: I would say mostly self-determination; I had a clear understanding from a young age that I loved acting. But in this business, you also have to be in the right place at the right time.

RD: Many people see acting as being about glamour, acclaim and good money, but is it really like that?

Hennessy: All we hear about in the press are the A-list actors’ salaries, the $20-million salaries, which is not really the case for most. When you do luck into a role – and thankfully I have a great job and I’m earning more than I thought I ever would – you still don’t know if you’ll ever work again. I learned a long time ago that if I got $200 for a role, it went right in the bank, except $5 a day to buy some food. It’s wonderful to have some security now – but still, right into the bank!
It turns out I'm having more difficulty even getting the images onto this screen. If someone would like to offer advice on how to do that, I would greatly appreciate it.